Allison Pearson
Pages: 320
Year: 2007
It’s a rite of passage in a teenage girl’s life to fall madly in love with a pop God. For me, it was at age 14 and the object of my affection was Neil Finn. I slavishly scoured music magazines for any mention of him, plastered my wall in Crowded House posters and listened to nothing but his music for months on end, driving my family half mad in the process.
For Petra Williams, the 13-year-old heroine at the centre of Allison Pearson’s new novel I Think I Love You, her pop deity of choice is 1974’s hottest property David Cassidy. Together with her best friend Sharon, the two spend hours huddled together obsessively pouring over “The Essential David Cassidy” fanzine, soaking up every last detail about the Partridge Family heartthrob while simultaneously trying to win favour with super snooty high school drama queen Gillian Edwards.
Meanwhile in London, Bill Finn is an unemployed wannabe rock journalist fast running out of options when an opening at “The Essential David Cassidy” mag is offered his way. Not quite Rolling Stone, it is however the “bible” to lust ravaged teen girls all over Great Britain. But what the hordes of infatuated fans don’t know is the letters that appear each month seemingly from their idol are actually the fictitious ramblings of a disenchanted Bill.
So when Bill is tasked with compiling the “Ultimate David Cassidy Quiz” for the magazine with first prize a trip for two to California to meet David, Petra and Sharon know their chance to meet the love of their life has finally arrived, if only they could answer all 50 questions.
Flash forward 20 years and Petra is an about to be divorced mother to a teenage daughter with her own fangirl crush. Bill meanwhile is the boss of a staple of successful magazines. Their lives collide when with the death of Petra’s disapproving mother reveals Petra and Sharon were the winners of that long ago David Cassidy trivia competition.
Comparisons between this novel and Allison Pearson’s mega successful debut I Don’t Know How She Does It are inevitable and it was always going to be difficult following up on a book which was translated into 32 languages and sold a staggering 3.5 million copies. Unfortunately, while a pleasant enough read, I Think I Love You is not in the same league as its wonderful predecessor.
I could completely relate to the young Petra, her pop star fixations and her search for approval from the most popular and pretty girl in school. Her angst and despair were mine all those years ago too and Pearson’s writing evoked that painful ache of unrequited love in me again. However, the length of time devoted to the teenage Petra felt overlong and slowed the pace of the novel down. The adult Petra failed to drag herself out from under the clutches of her domineering mother, even after her passing, and establish herself as a force to be reckoned with; life seems to just happen to Petra, she doesn’t make it happen.
Then there’s Bill; a caricature of the high achieving but lonesome in love romantic lead. His and Petra’s predictable love affair lacks the necessary spark and sizzle; there’s simply no conflict to reconcile – they just seem to get together without an awful lot of romance or fuss – most unsatisfying in a chick lit novel.
Despite its flaws, I Think I Love You is certainly well crafted and well written and the initial chapters are particularly enjoyable as well as teaching you an awful lot about David Cassidy – Pearson’s own teenage crush in real life. And if you can forgive Pearson for not providing a less than tumultuous path to love for our heroine, then this chick lit novel is for you.
- Kelly